Reviews and revenue

Should Small Businesses Pay for Review Services?

Paying for software that helps you ask every real customer for a review can be money well spent. Paying for reviews, or for anyone who promises a rating, is banned. Here is how to tell the difference before you sign.

A small business owner at a desk comparing two printed proposals with prices circled, a laptop showing a software pricing page beside a calculator and coffee.

Should small businesses pay for review services? It depends entirely on what the service does. Paying for software or help that makes it easier to ask every genuine customer for a review, track what they say and reply on time is legitimate, and for a busy business it can pay for itself. Paying for reviews, for a guaranteed number of stars, or for anyone who will "remove" honest negative reviews is a different thing: it breaks Google's rules and, in the UK, the US and Australia, consumer law.

The trouble is that both are sold under the same name. This guide explains how to tell them apart, when it is worth paying at all, and the questions to ask a vendor before you sign anything.

Two very different things called "review services"

Usually worth considering Never pay for
Software that sends a review request to every customer after a visit Reviews written by people who were not customers
Monitoring that alerts you to new reviews across platforms Review "packages" or a guaranteed number of reviews
Help drafting replies, especially to negative reviews Discounts, gifts or prize draws in exchange for reviews
Analysis of what your reviews, and your competitors', are saying Tools that only send requests to customers who said they were happy
Widgets that show genuine reviews on your website Services that promise to delete genuine negative reviews

The line is simple: you can pay to make it easier for real customers to share their real experience. You cannot pay to change what that experience looks like.

What Google and the law say

Google's policy

Google's Maps user-generated content policy says that fake engagement will be removed, bans reviews that have been paid for directly or in kind, and says businesses must not offer payment, discounts or free goods or services in exchange for reviews. It also forbids businesses to "selectively solicit positive reviews from customers", which rules out any tool that filters out unhappy customers before sending them to Google.

Google's own advice on getting more reviews is to share a review link or QR code with customers and reply to the reviews you get. Both are free.

The UK

Fake reviews, and reviews that hide the fact they were incentivised, are a banned practice under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024. The Competition and Markets Authority published guidance for businesses on fake reviews in April 2025, when the rules took effect, and it now has the power to fine businesses directly. Separately, the CMA secured commitments from Google to put prominent warnings on the profiles of businesses found inflating their ratings with fake reviews and to stop them receiving new reviews.

The US and Australia

In the US, the Federal Trade Commission's final rule on fake reviews and testimonials bans buying fake reviews, paying for reviews conditioned on a particular sentiment and suppressing reviews through threats, and lets the FTC seek civil penalties. In Australia, fake or misleading reviews can breach the Australian Consumer Law's rules on misleading conduct, which the ACCC enforces.

The practical point for an owner: if a vendor's results depend on any of the practices in the right-hand column of the table above, the risk lands on your business, not theirs.

What our data says about the promises vendors make

Two claims come up again and again in review service sales pitches. Our data on 524,000 recent Google reviews and the ratings of 46,800 businesses puts both in context.

"Replying to every review will raise your rating." In our data it does not, at least not visibly. Businesses that reply to three quarters or more of their reviews have a median Google rating of 4.7; businesses that never reply have a median of 4.9. What the busy repliers do have is more reviews: a median of 378, against 202 for businesses that never reply. Replies are good practice and customers expect them, but they are not a ratings lever. A tool that helps you reply is worth paying for only if it saves you time.

"We will get you to 5.0." A perfect score is common on very few reviews and rare on many. In our data, 70% of businesses with fewer than ten reviews are at 5.0, against 1% of those with more than a thousand. A vendor promising a high rating at scale is promising something genuine reviews rarely produce. Our guide to spotting fake Google reviews shows the patterns customers and Google look for.

A small business owner at a desk reading a software contract with a highlighter, a laptop open beside it
Read what a review service actually does before you sign.

Do you need to pay for review services at all?

Many small businesses do not. Before you pay for review services, check whether the free route covers you:

  • Your review link and QR code. Google Business Profile gives you both. Print the QR code on receipts and table cards, and put the link in your follow-up email or text.
  • Your booking or invoicing system. Many already send a follow-up message after an appointment. Add your review link to it.
  • A weekly half hour. Read and reply to new reviews at a fixed time each week.

Paying starts to make sense when:

  1. You serve many customers a week and want every one of them asked, without staff remembering to do it.
  2. You have several locations and need one view of reviews across them.
  3. You are on several platforms (Google, Trustpilot, Facebook, TripAdvisor, a trade directory) and keep missing reviews.
  4. You want to understand the market, not just your own reviews: what customers praise and complain about across all your competitors.

Our article on the ROI of review management has a simple way to estimate whether a paid tool is worth it for you, and the best platforms to collect customer feedback compares the kinds of tool available.

Questions to ask before you sign

  1. Does it send review requests to every customer, or only some? If it asks customers to rate you first and sends only the happy ones to Google, that is review gating and breaks Google's policy.
  2. Does it guarantee a number of reviews or a rating? Nobody can guarantee genuine reviews. A guarantee means the reviews are not genuine or the requests are not neutral.
  3. Does it offer anything to customers for reviewing? Discounts, prize draws and loyalty points for reviews are incentives Google prohibits.
  4. What does it promise about negative reviews? A service can help you report reviews that break Google's rules. One that promises to remove honest criticism is either overpromising or using tactics that can fall foul of the law.
  5. What will the request say? Read the default wording. Our guide to what not to say when asking for a review lists phrases that cause trouble.
  6. Who owns the customer data, and what happens when you leave? Check the contract length, the notice period and whether you can export your contacts.

The red flags in one place

  • "Guaranteed five-star reviews" or "100 reviews in 30 days".
  • A satisfaction check that decides who gets sent to Google.
  • Reviews from accounts the vendor controls, or "review exchange" schemes with other businesses.
  • Offers to remove negative reviews for a fee, regardless of whether they break any policy.
  • Requests that suggest what the customer should write.

If you are on the other side of this, being offered money to write reviews, read can you make money writing Google reviews.

The short version

  • Pay for review services only when they help you ask every real customer, track reviews or understand them; never for reviews, ratings or removals.
  • Google bans paid, incentivised and selectively solicited reviews, and fake reviews are illegal in the UK, the US and Australia.
  • Replying to reviews is worth doing but, in our data, is not linked to a higher rating; judge reply tools on time saved.
  • Most small businesses can start free with a review link, a QR code and a weekly habit. See how to get more Google reviews.
  • If you want to know how your reviews compare with every competitor, a Rate My Ratings market report reads the whole market for you.

Frequently asked questions

Is it legal to pay for Google reviews?

No. Paying for reviews, or offering discounts or gifts in exchange for them, breaks Google's content policy. Fake reviews and undisclosed incentivised reviews are banned under UK consumer law since April 2025, the FTC's 2024 rule in the US, and the Australian Consumer Law's ban on misleading conduct.

Is review management software worth it for a small business?

It can be if you serve many customers, run several locations or collect reviews on several platforms, because it saves staff time and makes sure every customer is asked. A small business with a few customers a week can usually do the same for free with a review link, a QR code and a weekly routine.

What is review gating and why is it banned?

Review gating means asking customers how satisfied they are first and sending only the happy ones to leave a public review. Google's policy forbids businesses to selectively solicit positive reviews, so a tool that does this puts your profile at risk.

Can a company remove negative Google reviews for me?

Only reviews that break Google's rules, such as fake reviews, conflicts of interest or abuse, can be removed, and you can report those yourself for free. A company that promises to remove genuine negative reviews for a fee is overpromising or using tactics that may be unlawful.

Rate My RatingsNewsletter

What reviews say about local markets, in your inbox.

New articles and findings from the blog, as they're published.

Check your inbox.

If this address isn't subscribed yet, we've sent it a link to confirm. Nothing is sent until you click it.

From the blog to your market

See what customers say about your market.

Each Rate My Ratings report reads every public review of every comparable business in one category and one location, and turns them into a five-part document you can act on.

  • What you getOne password-protected web document in five parts: Overview, Experience, Persona, Benchmark, Strategy.
  • Where the data comes fromPublic reviews on Google Maps, attributed to the business that received them and presented in aggregate.
  • How it's pricedA one-time purchase per market. No account, no card on file, nothing to cancel.